Temptations NYC: Full Guide to NYC's Former On-Premise Swinger Club

Temptations NYC was, for years, one of Manhattan’s best-known on-premise swinger clubs—a two-floor, BYOB lifestyle venue where couples and select singles could explore their sexuality in a structured, consent-first environment right in the heart of New York City. Officially described as an on-premise, two-floor swinger club in the borough of Manhattan, Temptations NYC operated as a private, reservation-only space: no walk-ins, no public address on flyers, and no sharing the location outside of confirmed guests. Everything about the way it ran—RSVP-only entry, email-only address disclosure, and clear etiquette expectations—was designed to protect privacy and keep the vibe sexy but safe.

Inside, the club leaned heavily into being a comfortable space to “give in to your temptations” without pressure. It was strictly BYOB and cash-only at the door, with bottles checked in at the bar and returned at the end of the night, lockers and coat check available for guests’ belongings, and a strong emphasis on appearance: a Dress-To-Impress dress code that explicitly banned gym wear, sweats, ripped jeans, flip-flops, pajamas, and casual headgear. Temptations expected guests to show up groomed, stylish, and presentable—this was a lifestyle club, not a dive bar, and the dress standards reflected that.

What really set Temptations NYC apart for many lifestyle couples, though, was its explicit, written consent policy. The club wasn’t shy about spelling it out: “No means no. Maybe means no.” Guests were told clearly that any coercion, intimidation, or non-consensual touching would result in removal, and that seeing people nude or playing in the open never gave anyone the right to touch them. Contraceptives were readily available in every private room and play area, and guests were reminded that they were never required to undress or participate—watching from the sidelines in full clothing was completely acceptable. For a lot of newcomers, that combination of erotic energy and firm boundaries made Temptations feel approachable rather than overwhelming.

Temptations NYC was more than just a swingers’ spot, too; thanks to its size and reputation, it became a go-to venue for outside promoters hosting both swinger and non-swinger events. Alongside the club’s own lifestyle parties, the space regularly appeared on flyers for BDSM and kink events like DarkSide and IMPACT, adding a cross-genre appeal for people curious about both swinging and kink. That made it a kind of hub in the NYC adult nightlife ecosystem: a place where different corners of the lifestyle overlapped under one roof, each with its own nights, rules, and communities.

By 2025, however, Temptations NYC’s story had reached a turning point. After a period of intense legal scrutiny and nuisance-abatement action from the city, major news outlets reported that the club was being targeted in court over allegations related to prostitution and alcohol service, which the operator publicly disputed as a misunderstanding of the swinger lifestyle. In early 2025, the club posted an emotional closure announcement on its own site, stating with “mixed emotions and great sadness” that Temptations NYC was closing, while thanking loyal members and staff and hinting that this was “so long for now,” not a permanent goodbye.

This guide looks back at Temptations NYC as it was when it was open—how the events worked, who was welcome, what the rules and amenities were, and why so many swinger and open-minded couples considered it a must-visit stop in New York City—while also being honest about its closure and the context around it.

What Temptations NYC Was (Club Identity & Philosophy)

Temptations NYC defined itself very clearly: it was an on-premise, two-floor swinger club in the Manhattan borough of New York City, dedicated to hosting BYOB swinger lifestyle events. It wasn’t just a bar that happened to be “lifestyle-friendly” – it was built from the ground up as a swinger venue, where the expectation was that people were there to flirt, explore, and possibly play, all within a structured, rules-driven environment.

From the start, Temptations framed itself around privacy, discretion, and control. First-time guests could not simply walk in; they had to submit a reservation for a specific event, read the event details carefully, and then wait for an email confirmation with the exact location. The club asked guests not to share that address with anyone else and explicitly stated that walk-ins were not allowed. That combination – hidden location, RSVP-only entry, and strict control of who comes through the door – was a big part of how the club protected both its members and its own reputation.

Culturally, Temptations positioned itself as a place where people could comfortably explore their sexuality without pressure. It was crystal clear in the FAQ that there was no requirement to undress or participate in any play. Guests were free to stay fully clothed anywhere in the club, to watch without joining in, and to leave at any time if they no longer felt like engaging. This is an important distinction: some swinger clubs nudge guests toward mandatory robe areas or “clothing optional” floors; Temptations explicitly rejected that model and reassured people that simply observing was a valid way to spend the night.

The club’s consent philosophy was written in bold, unambiguous terms. Their policy spelled it out:

“NO MEANS NO. MAYBE MEANS NO.”
Coercion, intimidation, or sexual harassment were not tolerated.
Anyone pushing their date or another guest, or groping/touching without permission, would be removed.
Seeing nudity or open play was not an invitation to touch.

This language wasn’t fluffy marketing; it was actionable: if you broke those rules, you were out. For swinger couples and open-minded guests, that made the venue feel safer and more predictable.

Temptations NYC also distinguished itself by being BYOB and on-premise. Guests brought their own liquor, beer, or wine, checked bottles in with the bartender, and were served their own alcohol throughout the night, then took their bottles home at the end. The club provided free sodas and juices, sold water and Red Bull, and operated as a cash-only venue with an ATM on-site. That BYOB structure placed the focus on the social and sexual experience rather than heavy bar sales, and it gave regulars a familiar, almost “private party” feel each time they visited.

“Swingtown is so great in am having so much fun and it’s the best site to visit and enjoy. The people are so friendly.” -JS12

Philosophically, Temptations sat at the intersection of swinger culture and the broader alternative nightlife scene. While it was first and foremost a swinger club, it also became a popular venue for outside promoters, including BDSM and kink events like DarkSide and IMPACT. Those events had their own rules and dress codes, but the fact that they chose Temptations as a host venue says a lot about its size, layout, and reputation in the adult community. For many in the lifestyle, Temptations NYC wasn’t just another club; it was a recognizable hub where different strands of alternative sexuality overlapped, under a set of very clear, consent-first house rules.

Who Could Attend and How Entry Worked

Temptations NYC was open to a mix of couples and singles, but exactly who could attend on a given night depended on the event type and the club’s ratio rules. It was not a “show up and see what happens” kind of venue; you had to fit their guest criteria and follow their reservation process very closely.

Reservation-Only Entry and Location Privacy

Temptations NYC took privacy seriously, starting with how you got in the door. For first-time guests, the process looked like this:

You chose a specific event from their calendar.
You submitted a reservation for that event.
You were expected to read the event details carefully before sending your RSVP.
If accepted, you received an email confirmation with the exact location and check-in details.

The club asked guests not to share the address with anyone. Walk-ins were not allowed, and people who were not on the reservation list or did not have a confirmation were simply not admitted. Even regulars had to follow the event’s RSVP rules; Temptations operated on the principle that privacy and discretion started before you ever walked into the building.

Couples, Single Women and Single Men

Temptations NYC was a swinger club first, but it did not treat every night the same. The type of guest allowed depended on the event:

Some events allowed couples and single women only.
Other events explicitly allowed single men, but only when the event description said so.

The FAQ was very clear:

Single men could not attend couples-only events.
They could not “pay extra” or talk their way into couples-only nights.

For couples-only events, the club also defined exactly what counted as a couple:

A couple was recognized as one female and one male for ratio and pricing purposes.
Every male on a couples-only night had to have a female date.

That meant:

A male–male–female triad (MMF) could not all attend a couples-only event together, because that would count as two men and one woman.
A female–female–male triad (FFM) could attend, because additional women were allowed on couples-only nights.

This level of specificity told guests exactly what to expect in the room and helped Temptations keep the male-to-female ratio where they wanted it.

Eligibility wasn’t just about your relationship structure; it was also about how you behaved. Temptations made it very clear that all guests were expected to carry themselves in a respectful way. Their consent policy spelled out the rules in plain language:

No means no.
Maybe means no.
Coercion, intimidation, and sexual harassment were not tolerated.
Groping or touching anyone without permission was grounds for removal.
Seeing people nude or playing in the open did not give anyone the right to touch them.

If a guest was pushy with their partner or another guest, they were removed. That meant that, in practice, “being eligible” to attend Temptations wasn’t a one-time hurdle. You also had to show that you could respect boundaries and contribute to a safe atmosphere if you wanted to be welcome there over time.

Participation Is Optional: Observers Welcome

One of the things that made Temptations NYC accessible to newer couples was its stance on participation. The FAQ was explicit:

You were not required to undress at any point.
You were not required to have sex or engage in any activity.
You could remain fully dressed throughout both levels of the club.
You could simply observe play without joining in.

For many first-timers, that took a lot of pressure off. It meant you could come to see how swinger events worked, read the room, and go at your own pace. If you decided you weren’t ready to play, you could still enjoy the atmosphere, talk to people, and leave feeling comfortable rather than pushed.

“We are very excited to have joined Swing Towns. We have already chatted and met some fun people. We look forward to meeting many more friends and having a great time making new connections.” –
IzzyBlossomKatee

Accessibility and Practical Eligibility

Temptations NYC also made a point of saying that:

The venue was wheelchair-accessible, with an elevator in the building.
Guests who needed help on-site could ask staff for assistance.

On the practical side, there were a few more quiet eligibility filters built into their policies:

The club was cash-only at the door, so guests had to be prepared to pay in cash (an ATM was available on-site).
It was BYOB, and guests were expected to bring their own beer, wine or liquor and check it at the bar.
Dress-to-impress was mandatory; guests were expected to be groomed and presentable, not in gym wear, sweats, ripped jeans, pajamas or casual footwear.

Although the FAQ didn’t spell out an exact age minimum, Temptations was clearly an adults-only club, and guests would have been expected to present government-issued ID if asked.

Taken together, Temptations NYC’s eligibility rules created a very specific environment: reservation-only, privacy-focused, couples and single women prioritized, single men allowed only at designated events, clear boundaries around relationship structures on couples-only nights, and a strong expectation of respectful, consent-aware behaviour from everyone in the room.

Dress Code and How to Present Yourself

Temptations NYC treated dress and appearance as a core part of the experience. This wasn’t a place to show up in whatever you wore to run errands; it was a swinger club with a clear expectation that guests would put genuine effort into how they looked.

Dress-To-Impress Is Non-Negotiable

Temptations NYC had a straightforward rule: Dress-To-Impress.

Guests were expected to be nicely groomed and presentable. The FAQ literally reminded people: “This is a swinger club; please put some effort into how you present yourself.” The goal was to maintain a sexy, stylish atmosphere where everyone felt like they were at a special event, not a casual neighborhood bar.

What Was Not Allowed

The club published a specific list of banned clothing items. These were never acceptable:

Gym attire
Sweatpants
Track suits
Pajamas
Slippers or flip flops
Baseball hats or fitted hats
Durags / dew-rags
Ripped jeans

If your outfit leaned lazy, sloppy, or “just lounging at home,” it went against their standards. Guests who ignored these rules risked being turned away at the door.

What They Wanted to See

Although Temptations didn’t give a formal list of “approved” outfits, their rules and tone made their expectations very clear:

For men:
- Dress shirts instead of T-shirts
- Nice jeans or trousers without rips, or dress pants
- Dress shoes or clean, stylish shoes (not athletic or beach footwear)
- Overall look: like you’re going to a good nightclub or upscale lounge
For women:
- Sexy dresses, skirts, or stylish outfits that feel nightclub-appropriate
- Lingerie or more revealing looks for later in the night, if desired
- Heels, boots, or other sexy footwear that still looks polished (no slippers/flip-flops)
- Hair, makeup, and accessories that make you feel confident and seductive

The idea was that everyone in the room should feel like they’re part of a deliberately erotic, adult nightlife environment rather than a casual hangout.

Grooming and General Presentation

The dress code went hand-in-hand with grooming. Temptations explicitly expected guests to:

Arrive clean, fresh, and well-kept
Avoid disheveled or “rolled out of bed” looks
Respect the effort other guests put into their appearance

For many lifestyle couples, this was part of the attraction: you could count on a room full of people who had put thought and effort into how they looked, which elevated the overall vibe.

How to Make Sure You Would Have Passed the Door

If you were planning an outfit for Temptations NYC back when it was open, the safest approach would have been:

Ask yourself: “Would I be comfortable wearing this to a nice nightclub where people dress to be noticed?”
Avoid anything that looks like gym wear, lounge wear, or sleepwear.
Make sure your clothes are clean, intact, and fit well.
Choose shoes that look intentional, not like you’re going to the beach or the corner store.

“I recommend swingtowns because it’s the first site that even as a free profile you can still connect with ppl. I have since upgraded to lifetime but me and my wife have met some really fun cpls since we started on this site so we fully recommend swingtowns.” -TheRowan

That “Dress-To-Impress” standard helped define the feel of Temptations NYC: not just a place to play, but a place to show up as your best, sexiest, most put-together self.

Temptations NYC was very explicit that it was a place to explore fantasies safely, not a free-for-all. Its FAQ laid out some of the clearest consent language you’ll see from a swinger club, and that shaped how play worked on both floors of the venue.

Temptations didn’t leave consent up to interpretation. The club’s official policy spelled out a few key rules:

No means no.
Maybe means no.
If a guest was pushy with their own date or with someone else, they were removed.
If a guest groped or touched anyone without permission, they were removed.
Watching people nude or playing in the open did not give anyone the right to touch them.

They also stated that any form of coercion, intimidation or sexual harassment was not tolerated. In practice, that meant consent wasn’t just assumed because you were in a swinger space; it had to be explicit and ongoing.

No Pressure to Undress or Participate

One of Temptations NYC’s big differentiators was its stance on participation:

Guests were not required to undress at any point.
There was no rule forcing you into lingerie or nudity on a specific floor.
You could remain fully dressed throughout both levels of the club.
You could simply observe and not participate in any play.

For newer lifestyle couples or cautious first-timers, this was huge. You could come, feel the environment, see how people interacted, and decide if and when you were ready to join in. There was no “robe rule,” no mandatory changing area, and no requirement to prove you were “really lifestyle” by playing.

Safer-Sex Supplies and Support

Temptations NYC backed up its consent stance with practical safer-sex support:

Condoms were provided and readily available in every private room and play area.
If you needed female condoms, dental dams or towels, you could request them from the floor attendant.

That meant you didn’t have to carry your own full kit around the club, and it reinforced the idea that safer sex was the expectation, not an afterthought.

Spaces, Smoking and Comfort

Even though Temptations did not have showers, it put thought into how guests could feel physically comfortable during a long night out:

Lockers were available for storing clothes, phones and valuables; you could bring your own lock or use a club lock with a refundable deposit.
Coat check was available for a per-item fee.
A separate smoking room existed for cigarette, cigar and cannabis use, so smoke didn’t invade the rest of the club.
Hookah was sold on select nights.

The club also noted that the building had an elevator and that staff could assist anyone who needed help moving around, making the venue accessible to guests using wheelchairs or those with mobility issues.

Food, Drinks and BYOB Safety

Temptations NYC ran as a BYOB space:

Guests brought their own liquor, beer or wine.
Bottles were checked in with the bartender on arrival and served back to you through the night.
At the end of the night, you could take your bottle back with you.
Poland Spring water and Red Bull were sold.
A variety of juices and sodas were available free of charge.

“Swing Towns knows what’s up! Finally a platform where like minded people can connect.” -Cboy6983

For food, they:

Offered complimentary snacks at the bar.
Served a hot-food buffet only on select nights and special occasions.
Did not allow outside food to be brought into the club.

All payments at the door were cash-only, with an ATM on-site. That “cash at the door, BYOB inside” model kept things simple and underscored that Temptations was running more like a private party venue than a generic nightclub.

No Refunds and Realistic Expectations

Temptations NYC was blunt about one last rule: there were no refunds, for any reason. If the crowd wasn’t to your taste, if the event vibe didn’t match your fantasies, or if you simply didn’t connect with anyone, you still paid the full amount.

For lifestyle couples, that meant two things:

You needed to arrive with realistic expectations and an open mind.
You were responsible for your own experience; the club provided the space, rules and amenities, but not guaranteed chemistry.

Put together, these policies show how Temptations NYC tried to balance erotic freedom with structure: clear consent rules, no pressure to play, safer-sex supplies, BYOB controls, accessibility and defined house rules around behaviour and refunds. For many couples and singles, that mix of freedom plus guardrails was exactly what made Temptations feel like a safe place to test, push or fully indulge their desires.

Amenities, Layout and Overall Experience

Even though Temptations NYC is now closed, its FAQ and member feedback make it pretty clear what a night there felt like when it was open: structured, sensual, and logistically very easy to navigate.

Two-Floor, On-Premise Setup

Temptations NYC described itself as an on-premise, two-floor swinger club in Manhattan. That meant:

Social and play spaces were stacked vertically within one private venue.
You didn’t need to leave the building or go off-site to play.
You could move between socializing and play at your own pace, without losing privacy.

While the FAQ doesn’t list room-by-room details, the fact that it explicitly mentions “every private room and play area” for condoms tells you there were multiple dedicated play zones, both open and private.

Lockers, Coat Check and Managing Your Stuff

The club was set up to make it easy to relax without worrying about your belongings:

Lockers available for personal items like clothes, phones and wallets.
You could bring your own lock or use a club-provided lock with a $10 deposit.
Coat check was offered at $4 per item, which is useful in NYC winters when everyone arrives layered up.

For swinger couples, that’s a big deal: you could stash phones (for privacy), heavy outerwear and extra clothes, and then move freely between floors and play areas without juggling bags.

BYOB Bar Setup and Drinks

Temptations NYC ran as a BYOB establishment, with a clear process:

You brought your own liquor, beer or wine.
On arrival, you checked in your bottles at the bar with the bartender.
The bartenders served your alcohol back to you throughout the night.
At the end of the night, you could take your bottles back when you left.

On top of that:

Poland Spring water and Red Bull were available for purchase.
A variety of juices and sodas were free of charge as mixers.

All payments at the door were cash only, but there was an ATM on-site if you needed it. This reinforced the “private party” feel: no credit-card trail at the bar, no surprise drink tabs when you’re trying to leave.

“This is an amazing place to explore and experience. The best online platform for swinging.” -Decentfinder

Food, Snacks and Going the Distance

Temptations NYC tried to support longer nights with simple, practical food options:

Complimentary snacks were available at the bar.
A hot-food buffet was set out on select nights and special occasions.
Guests were not allowed to bring in outside food.

So while it wasn’t a full-service restaurant, there was enough to keep you from getting lightheaded after a few drinks or a long play session.

Smoking, Cannabis and Hookah

Instead of forcing smokers onto the street or letting smoke flood the main rooms, Temptations had a dedicated solution:

A separate smoking room for cigarettes, cigars and cannabis.
Hookah was sold on select nights.

That setup made it easier to maintain air quality in the social and play areas while still giving smokers and cannabis users a space of their own.

Accessibility and Comfort

Accessibility was explicitly built into the FAQ:

The club was wheelchair-accessible, with an elevator in the building.
Guests who needed help on-site were told to ask a staff member for assistance.

Combined with lockers, coat check, and clear rules, this made Temptations feel more like a professional, organized venue than a haphazard underground party.

Overall Vibe: Practical, Structured, Erotic

Put all these amenities together and you get a very specific kind of experience:

You arrive, check in, drop your bottle with the bartender, and secure your belongings.
You can move freely between two floors of social and play space without lugging anything around.
You have easy access to condoms and safer-sex items, snacks, drinks and mixers.
Smokers have their own room.
You never have to undress if you don’t want to, and you know exactly where to go if you do.

For swinger couples and open-minded couples, that mix of logistical ease + clear structure + erotic intent is a big part of why Temptations NYC became such a well-known lifestyle destination before its closure.

Pricing, Payments and Refund Policy

Temptations NYC didn’t post a detailed public price list in its FAQ, but it did spell out exactly how guests paid, what was and wasn’t included, and how strictly it handled refunds. When you put those pieces together, you get a clear picture of the financial side of a night at the club when it was open.

Cash-Only at the Door

All payments at Temptations NYC were handled in person, in cash, at the door. The FAQ made two points very clear:

Payments were not made online.
The club accepted only cash when checking in.

If you arrived without enough cash, there was an ATM on-site, but the expectation was that you came prepared to cover your entry and any extras like coat check.

This approach fit with the club’s private-party feel: no ticket vendor, no card swipe at the door, no pre-paid online receipts tied to your name.

Event-Based Pricing (Without Published Numbers)

While Temptations NYC explained the payment method, it did not publish specific door prices in the FAQ you provided. Instead, pricing was tied to:

The type of event (regular swinger night, couples-only event, special themed party, or promoter-hosted event).
Your role (couple, single woman, single man, or part of a triad).
Sometimes, the promoter’s own structure, for non-swinger events like DarkSide or IMPACT.

That means:

You could not rely on a single fixed price for all nights.
The exact cost for any given event would be listed in the event description, RSVP page, or promoter details rather than a static FAQ chart.

Given that the club is now closed, it would not be accurate or responsible to quote specific historical prices; those were event-specific and subject to change.

What Your Entry Fee Typically Included

Even without posted numbers, the FAQ and club setup tell us what your money generally covered when Temptations was open:

Access to both floors of the on-premise swinger club
Use of private and open play areas
Use of the BYOB bar setup, where bartenders served from the bottle you checked in
Access to free mixers (sodas and juices)
Availability of complimentary snacks at the bar
Use of condoms in all private rooms and play areas
Availability of female condoms, dental dams and towels via floor attendants
Basic comfort amenities like lockers (with refundable lock deposit) and a separate smoking room

On select nights, your cover charge also effectively gave you access to:

A hot-food buffet
A DJ and a more “club-like” party atmosphere

For promoter-hosted events, what was included could vary slightly, but the underlying infrastructure remained the same: two-floor on-premise venue, BYOB bar system, and swinger-friendly layout.

“I am enjoying swingtown and the way it is run. Hope to meet some great people who enjoy healthy sexy fun together. Life is tooo short not to.” -teaser71902

What Cost Extra

A few items sat outside your basic entry fee:

Coat check at a fixed, per-item price (listed as $4 per item in the FAQ).
Lock deposits if you did not bring your own lock (listed as a $10 deposit).
Bottled water (Poland Spring) and Red Bull, which were sold rather than provided free.
Hookah, available for purchase on select nights.

You also needed to factor in:

Transportation or parking
Any pre-club dinner or post-club plans

The club itself focused on providing the adult environment, not on bundling in extras like full meals or premium bottle service.

No Refund Policy

Temptations NYC was very blunt about refunds:

It did not give refunds for any reason.

If the other guests were not to your liking, if the ratio or energy felt off, or if the event itself did not match your expectations, there were still no refunds. That policy applied regardless of whether you stayed all night or left early.

For lifestyle guests, this meant:

You needed to arrive with realistic expectations and a flexible attitude.
You had to treat the cover charge as the price of access to a curated environment, not a guarantee of a perfect fantasy lineup.

Pricing After the Closure

With the official 2025 announcement that Temptations NYC was closing, any past pricing became historical only. The site’s closure message thanked members and staff and framed the shutdown as “so long for now,” but there are:

No current events
No active price lists
No valid door charges to quote

For your blog, the most accurate way to cover pricing today is to:

Describe the structure (cash-only, event-based, BYOB, no refunds).
Avoid inventing or freezing specific prices that may have varied over time.
Emphasize that Temptations NYC is now closed and that any future incarnation, if it appears, may adopt a completely different pricing model.

In short, when Temptations NYC was open, your money bought you entry into a structured, on-premise, BYOB swinger environment with clear rules, solid amenities and a consent-driven culture—but never a guarantee of a particular experience, crowd or outcome.

What a Night at Temptations NYC Was Like

Even though Temptations NYC is now closed, the FAQ and house rules give us a pretty clear picture of how a typical night used to unfold. Think of this section as a “reconstruction” of the experience for swinger couples and open-minded couples who are curious what it was actually like to be there.

Before You Ever Arrived

A Temptations night started long before you reached the building:

You picked a specific event and submitted a reservation.
You carefully read the event description (to see if it allowed single men, was couples-only, or was a promoter/kink night).
If accepted, you got an email with the exact location and details.
You were asked not to share the address with anyone else.

There were no walk-ins. If your name wasn’t on the list, you simply weren’t getting in. That alone set the tone: this was a private, curated, RSVP-only environment.

Arrival and Check-In

Once you reached the venue and took the elevator up, the flow generally looked like this:

Front desk check-in: You checked in with staff, paid cash at the door, and confirmed your reservation.
BYOB drop-off: If you brought liquor, wine, or beer, you handed your bottle(s) to the bartender, who tagged them and served from them throughout the night.
Lockers and coat check:
- You could use lockers for phones, clothing, and valuables (with your own lock or a club lock for a refundable deposit).
- Coat check was available per item, which was especially handy in colder months.

After that, you were free to move between the two floors, find your footing, and let your eyes adjust to the lighting and energy.

“Really enjoying Swingtowns a lot! Very easy to use the app and lots of great people too.” -KarandBri1970

Early Evening: Settling In

The beginning of the night was usually about warming up:

Couples and singles arrived over the first hour or so, often in “dress-to-impress” outfits with more revealing options hidden in their bags.
Most people started at the bar or main social areas, grabbing a drink (from their BYOB bottles) and doing a slow lap to see the crowd.
Conversation tended to be light at first—compliments on outfits, quick introductions, small talk about the city or lifestyle—and then deepened as comfort built.

If you were new, this phase was where you:

Got a feel for the etiquette in the room.
Noticed how people approached each other (usually with a smile and a gentle opener, not a hard proposition).
Observed how clearly yes and no were respected in practice.

Because Temptations was an on-premise, two-floor club, the night naturally divided into:

Social floor energy: more talking, flirting, drinking, and people-watching.
Play floor energy: more nudity, open play, and couples or groups drifting into private rooms.

Guests could move between floors at any time, and the club’s rules kept the environment feeling structured rather than chaotic:

You were never required to undress or play.
You could stay dressed and just observe, even on the more sexual floor.
You could watch open play without any obligation to join in.

That meant a typical night for a newer couple might involve staying mostly on the more social level, dipping down to the play floor to watch, then coming back up to talk about what they saw and how they felt.

Peak Time: When Play Usually Happened

As the night progressed and people had time to settle in:

More guests gravitated toward the play areas—either private rooms or open spaces where play was visible.
Couples who had been chatting earlier might exchange a more explicit “Are you two interested in playing?” conversation.
Some guests shifted into lingerie or more revealing outfits, using lockers and coat check to stash their earlier clothes.

Temptations’ consent rules shaped how this phase unfolded:

Touching without explicit permission was grounds for removal.
“No” and even “maybe” were treated as hard stops, not starting points for negotiation.
Guests knew that staff would back them up if anyone crossed a line or used pressure, intimidation, or harassment.

Safer-sex supplies were readily available, so once play started, you didn’t have to break the mood to go hunting for condoms or towels—those were already in the rooms or available from floor attendants.

Mixed Events vs. Couples-Only Nights

What the night felt like depended a lot on the event type:

Couples-only events (plus single women)
- The crowd was primarily M/F couples and women.
- MFM triads (two men and one woman) were not allowed in as a trio on these nights, to maintain ratios.
- The energy tended to be more couple-centric, with a focus on soft swaps, full swaps, and couple-to-couple play.
Events that allowed single men
- Single men could only attend when the event description explicitly allowed them.
- The vibe could shift toward more group play or stag/vixen/cuckold dynamics, depending on the theme.
Promoter nights (like DarkSide and IMPACT)
- These could be more kink-oriented, blending BDSM elements with swinger energy.
- Each promoter had its own rules, dress code, and expectations, which guests were told to review carefully.

A savvy couple would always read the event listing closely before reserving, so they knew what guest mix and energy to expect.

Ending the Night

As the night wound down:

Guests made their way back to the bar and social areas, re-dressed if needed, and decompressed.
People retrieved their bottles, coats and locker contents.
Those who connected strongly with other couples or singles might exchange contact details or talk about seeing each other at future events.

Because Temptations had a no-refund policy, some guests stayed later to “get the most” out of the night, while others left earlier once they felt they’d had their fill of socializing, watching, or playing.

What This Meant for New Couples

For swinger couples and open-minded couples, a typical night at Temptations NYC offered:

A structured, RSVP-only environment with clear rules.
A chance to observe first, participate later—or not at all.
A physical setup that made it easy to move between conversation, flirting and play.
The comfort of knowing there were explicit consent rules and staff willing to enforce them.

Now that Temptations NYC has closed, this flow is part of its legacy rather than something you can experience today—but understanding how it worked can help you evaluate other clubs and parties. If another venue offers a similar mix of clear rules, BYOB logistics, private play areas, and a no-pressure atmosphere, you’ll know you’re getting something modeled on the same kind of thoughtful, structured lifestyle experience Temptations was known for.

Unlock a World of Local Swingers & Lifestyle Events—Join SwingTowns for Free and Start Connecting Today

Temptations NYC may have closed its doors, but the world of swinging and open-minded exploration is very much alive—and it’s closer to you than you think. Whether you’re seeking your next lifestyle event, looking to meet other open-minded couples, or ready to discover the hottest swinger parties in your area, you don’t have to wait for another club to reopen.

Create your free SwingTowns profile and instantly connect with local swingers, explore upcoming lifestyle events, and meet couples who match your interests, boundaries, and chemistry. Your next unforgettable night starts with one simple step.

“We’ve only been in the LS for about a year but we have found some really great people using SwingTowns. Wish we would have found the website sooner.” -2Adults89

Temptations NYC: Full Guide to NYC’s Former On-Premise Swinger Club